Repair or replace your AC? A clear way to decide

Weigh age, repair cost, refrigerant and comfort with a simple calculator, then compare the options in writing.

On this page
  1. Start with a real diagnosis
  2. Try the calculator
  3. The factors that matter most
  4. What refrigerant has to do with it
  5. Compare the full picture
  6. How we handle replacement estimates
  7. Common questions
  8. Sources

Key takeaways

  • Our rule of thumb: if a repair costs more than about a third of replacement and the system is past about 12 years old, replacement usually wins. Below that, repair almost always wins.
  • ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement when a heat pump or AC is more than 10 years old, or a furnace more than 15.
  • R-22 systems can still be serviced, but no new R-22 has been made or imported in the U.S. since 2020, so refrigerant repairs can cost more.
  • Get a diagnosis and a written repair price before comparing. One failed part doesn’t mean the whole system is failing.

Start with a real diagnosis

A failed part tells you about that part, not the whole system. Before you compare replacement, get a diagnosis and a written repair price. Many summer breakdowns turn out to be a capacitor, a contactor or a clogged drain on a system that has years left in it.

Try the calculator

Interactive tool

Repair or replace calculator

Enter what you know. The numbers stay on your device.

10 years
$
$

From a written replacement estimate, if you have one. Without it, the calculator uses a rougher rule of thumb.

Repairs in the last two years
Refrigerant, from the outdoor unit’s label
Anything else?

Where this points

Repair likely makes sense

Based on what you entered, a repair looks reasonable. Ask for the written repair price and the warranty on the repair before you approve it.

What’s behind it

  • 10-year-old system. Middle-aged. The repair price matters most.
  • Age × repair price = $8,000. That’s over $5,000, a common rule of thumb for at least getting a replacement estimate.
  • Check the label on the outdoor unit. The refrigerant type affects repair costs.

This calculator is a starting point, not a quote. Make the decision on the written repair price and an in-home assessment.

The factors that matter most

Which way each factor leans
FactorLeans toward repairLeans toward replacement
AgeUnder about 10 yearsOver about 12 to 15 years
Repair priceA small share of replacementMore than about a third of replacement
Repair historyThe first major repairRepeated repairs in recent years
RefrigerantR-410A or newerR-22, now costly to service
ComfortComfortable when it runsHot rooms, humidity or noise problems
Energy useBills holding steadyBills rising without an explanation

What refrigerant has to do with it

Look at the label on your outdoor unit to find the refrigerant type.

  • R-22: U.S. production and import ended on January 1, 2020. Existing systems can still be serviced with recovered and recycled R-22, but it can be expensive.
  • R-410A: Common in systems installed over the last couple of decades. It’s still available for repairs, but U.S. supply is being reduced under a federal phasedown, so prices may rise over time.
  • R-454B and R-32: Newer refrigerants with a much lower climate impact. New home systems manufactured since 2025 use refrigerants like these. Under a 2026 EPA rule change, R-410A equipment built before 2025 can still be installed, so ask which refrigerant a quoted system uses.

Compare the full picture

A fair comparison puts the repair and the replacement side by side, in writing. For a replacement, ask exactly what’s included:

  • Which indoor and outdoor models are included, and are they a matched system?
  • What load calculation supports the size?
  • What duct, drain, electrical and thermostat work is included?
  • What labor and manufacturer warranties apply, and who registers them?
  • What isn’t included?

How we handle replacement estimates

Replacement estimates are free. We measure the home, run a load calculation and quote Good, Better and Best options in writing. You see both numbers, what the repair costs and what replacement costs, and the choice is yours. Financing is not currently available. Join our waitlist for an update when options are ready.

Common questions

It varies with installation quality, maintenance and how hard it runs, and our long cooling season is tough on equipment. ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement once a system is more than 10 years old, especially when repairs and bills are climbing.
Sometimes. We stock and service R-22, and if the repair doesn’t involve refrigerant and the system is otherwise healthy, a repair can make sense. When an R-22 system has a major failure, we quote a replacement alongside the repair so you can compare.
Usually it’s not a good idea. Indoor and outdoor parts are rated as matched systems, and pairing an old indoor coil with a new outdoor unit can hurt efficiency, reliability and warranty coverage.
A rule of thumb: multiply the system’s age by the repair price. If the result is over $5,000, consider getting a replacement estimate. It’s a quick screen, not a verdict, and it ignores comfort and efficiency.

Sources

We checked the facts in this guide against these public sources.

This guide is general information for homeowners, not a diagnosis of your system. If you smell gas or a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, leave the house and call 911 or your gas utility first.

CallBook a visit